Custard French Toast Cheese Melt

I discovered this dish on a Sunday morning when I was rummaging through the fridge, half-asleep, holding a block of Gruyère in one hand and a brioche loaf in the other. My roommate had just made French toast the day before, and I had leftover custard that seemed too good to waste. What if I turned it into something savory? Within minutes, I was assembling what would become my favorite brunch obsession—a sandwich that somehow convinced everyone at the table that sweet and savory breakfast could absolutely coexist.

The first time I made this for guests, I was genuinely nervous—there's something about combining two separate techniques that made me feel like I was taking a risk. But watching my friend take that first bite and immediately ask for the recipe before even finishing her slice? That's when I knew this wasn't just kitchen experimentation. It became the dish I make whenever I want someone to feel like I've done something special, even though the hardest part is remembering not to oversoak the bread.

Ingredients

• Eggs, whole milk, and heavy cream: These form the custard backbone—the eggs cook just enough to set while staying creamy, and the cream adds richness that makes every bite feel luxurious without tasting heavy.
• Granulated sugar: Just a tablespoon adds subtle sweetness that plays against the savory cheese and mustard, creating depth instead of confusion.
• Kosher salt and black pepper: These aren't afterthoughts; they're what make the custard taste intentional and balanced rather than one-dimensional.
• Dijon mustard (optional but recommended): A half teaspoon feels invisible but adds this sophisticated tang that elevates the whole thing—skip it if you want pure comfort, but try it once and you'll understand why it matters.
• Brioche or challah bread: The slight sweetness and pillowy texture of these breads handle the custard bath without falling apart, unlike sturdier loaves that can turn dense.
• Gruyère or sharp cheddar cheese: Gruyère melts like a dream and has this nutty complexity, while sharp cheddar brings more punch; mixing them gives you the best of both worlds.
• Unsalted butter and neutral oil: Butter alone burns too easily at the heat we need, so the oil keeps everything golden without bitterness.

Instructions

Make the custard mixture:

Whisk the eggs, milk, cream, sugar, salt, pepper, and mustard together in a shallow bowl until the mixture is smooth and the sugar dissolves. You want it to smell savory-rich, almost like a quiche, not sweet like typical French toast custard.

Build the sandwiches:

Lay out four slices of bread and top each with two slices of cheese, then crown with another bread slice. Press gently so they hold together; you want them snug enough to stay intact when dipped but not so tight that the cheese can't melt.

Heat your cooking surface:

Get your skillet or griddle over medium heat and let it warm for a minute, then add the butter and oil together, swirling them around until they're foaming slightly. The combination keeps the heat stable and prevents burning.

Dip with intention:

This is the moment that matters most—dip each sandwich into the custard for just a second or two per side, letting it coat but not soak. You're aiming for that golden, custardy exterior, not a soggy interior.

Pan-sear to golden:

Place the dipped sandwiches in the hot skillet and cook for three to four minutes on the first side, pressing gently with your spatula so they make full contact with the heat and brown evenly. Flip carefully and cook the other side until golden and the cheese is visibly melted, another three to four minutes.

Rest and slice:

Let each sandwich sit on a cutting board for two minutes—this brief rest lets the cheese set just enough so it doesn't ooze everywhere when you slice. Cut diagonally and serve immediately while everything is still warm and the cheese is at its creamiest.

Pin it

There's something almost magical about plating this sandwich and watching the melted cheese string when you cut into it, golden custard-soaked bread giving way to that warm, gooey center. It's the kind of dish that makes people pause mid-conversation and ask what you're making because suddenly their kitchen smells incredible.

When You Want to Play With Flavor

The beauty of this recipe is how easily it welcomes variations once you understand the base. I've made versions with fig jam layered between the cheese (the sweetness cuts through the richness beautifully), caramelized onions for a deeper savory note, or even a thin smear of whole-grain mustard for extra tang. Some mornings I'll use Swiss or fontina instead of Gruyère just to keep things interesting, and the sandwich shifts just enough to feel new without requiring any thought.

What to Serve It With

This sandwich is hearty enough to stand on its own, but it genuinely sings alongside something bright—a simple green salad with lemon vinaigrette balances the richness, and I've noticed tomato soup is practically written in the stars to go with it. Cold beverage-wise, I lean toward citrus or something herbal rather than plain water, just because the savory-sweet combo makes you want something with personality.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

If you're thinking ahead, assemble the cheese sandwiches, wrap them, and refrigerate for up to eight hours before cooking—this actually gives the bread time to absorb some of the cheese flavor and creates better texture when seared. The one rule is don't dip them ahead; that step needs to happen just before you cook, or you'll end up with bread that's heavy and waterlogged rather than custardy and tender.

• Keep leftover custard mixture covered in the fridge for three days if you want to make another batch later in the week.
• If somehow you have leftovers (though I've rarely seen this happen), reheat gently in a 300°F oven for five minutes rather than the microwave, which turns the bread tough.
• This dish is best eaten warm and fresh from the skillet, so plan to serve it right away and impress people while it's at its absolute peak.

Pin it

This sandwich has become my answer to the question of what to make when I want something that feels both indulgent and genuinely good to eat. It's teaching me that the best recipes aren't always about complicated techniques—sometimes it's just about combining the right things and knowing when to stop.

Recipe FAQs

→ What bread works best for this dish?

Brioche or challah bread, about half an inch thick, provides a tender crumb that soaks up custard without falling apart.

→ Which cheeses complement the custard soak well?

Gruyère or sharp cheddar melt smoothly and add a flavorful sharpness that pairs well with the custard's creaminess.

→ Can I add sweet or savory flavors to the filling?

Yes, a thin layer of fig jam or caramelized onions adds a delightful twist to the savory cheese filling.

→ How do I prevent the bread from becoming soggy?

Dip bread slices briefly into the custard to coat without soaking through, then cook on medium heat to achieve a crisp exterior.

→ Is it possible to prepare these sandwiches ahead of time?

Absolutely, assemble and refrigerate the sandwiches covered, then dip and cook just before serving to maintain freshness.